Showing posts with label July 2014. Show all posts
Showing posts with label July 2014. Show all posts

Friday, July 11, 2014

Review: The Girls of August

The Girls of August
Hardcover, 240 pages
Grand Central Publishing, 8 July 2014
2 stars

Four friends gather for an annual beach vacation, each year renting a house in a new location.  This began as a way to get away while their husbands were all in medical school together, and has become a way to reconnect with one another, calling each other the Girls of August.  When one of them dies tragically, their vacations are brought to a halt and their friendships gradually dwindle away.  When the widower remarries, the three women agree to a vacation to meet the new wife, a much younger woman who doesn't quite fit into the group.  Their vacation on the South Carolina coast will reveal the changes the women have undergone since their last time together.



*************************

I'm not entirely sure where to start with this review, because I almost didn't finish the book.  At 240 pages it was a quick read, which was an incredibly good thing.  Had it taken more than two or three hours to read this book, I would have put it down.  I was looking forward to a sweet, touching book about women supporting each other through their friendships, and instead I got a ridiculous, scrambled book about women acting like mean middle school girls.

The characters were flat, cardboard people that Siddons apparently couldn't be bothered to develop.  Until one of the characters began acting erratic and a major life event was revealed about halfway through the book, I honestly kept confusing two of the characters because there was so little depth to either of their characters.  What Siddons did reveal about their personalities through their behaviors was so hateful and mean that I couldn't imagine she was writing about characters she liked.  Grown women were catty, sarcastic, and downright cruel and bullying to one another.  Apparently this was because some of them were "going through things."  I didn't find this in the least bit believable.

The writing was painfully simple and uninspired.  These women were vacationing on a beautiful semi-private island off the coast of South Carolina and Siddons spent more time describing the decor of the house and the details of their food than the supposedly beautiful locale.  The story itself was jumbled and made no sense.  The women spend most of their trip bitching, sniping, and being generally unfriendly to the new wife and eventually even to each other.  Accusations of assault, sabotage, and affairs abound, and in the end...well, the ending came out of nowhere and made absolutely no sense.  When the bomb was dropped regarding a major event in the life of one of the women...I hardly paused in my reading.  There was so little build up to the announcement that I couldn't bring myself to care.  That, to me, is the sign of an unsuccessful book.

(I received a copy of this book from Grand Central Publishing in exchange for an honest review.)

Monday, July 7, 2014

Review: The City by Dean Koontz

The City
Hardcover, 416 pages
Bantam, 1 July 2014
3 stars

Jonah Kirk is the nine-year-old grandson of a top-notch piano player, the son of a extraordinarily talented lounge singer and an absentee father, and a musical prodigy in his own right.  He's just beginning to explore his musical gifts, when an accidental meeting with a group of very dangerous people has disastrous consequences.  Jonah is a young man coming of age in a remarkable family during a time when his city was coming of age as well.





*************************

Jonah Kirk, now in his late-50's, is telling the gripping story of a very important time in his young life.  Koontz is in his element here, weaving a story that is lyrical to read, though it takes some time to wade through.  The plot moves slowly, almost luxuriously so, because Koontz is so descriptive, taking his time to make sure you can visualize every bit of Jonah's city.  The city almost becomes a character itself due to Koontz vivid descriptions of its people, it's art, and it's architecture.  Koontz explores the idea of a city having a soul, as personified by "Pearl", the mysterious woman who teaches Jonah to interpret his dreams.  

This novel was as much a character study as it was the coming-of-age of Jonah.  The character development of the "good guy" characters - Kirk's family and friends - was rich and expansive.  Disappointingly, however, the "bad guy" characters felt one-dimensional and a bit stereotypical.  The characters sometimes felt as though they were being used to explore themes and not carry the story themselves.  Jonah's relationship (or lack of one) with his father, his dedication to his mother, his friendship with the quietly formidable Mr. Yoshioka, and his love of Amelia Pomerantz all felt as though they were just as important to the story as the plot itself.  When Koontz allowed the characters to shine on the page, the story was wonderful to read.  Unfortunately, sometimes too much space passed between these glimpses of brilliance.

My problem with this novel was perhaps in my expectations.  I am a long-time fan of Koontz's novels because they're usually such page turners.  An interesting main character, an intriguing premise, a whole lot of suspense, and a thrilling conclusion.  While The City definitely had an interesting main character, it was missing everything else.  It was by far a more philosophical novel than I'm used to from Koontz, and as a result it sometimes felt like work to read.  In the end, The City was a good book I just couldn't get into.

(I received a copy of this book from Bantam Books in exchange for an honest review.)